Home » City Council, Community » Election Central 2016: Sedona City Council Election Forum

Election Central 2016: Sedona City Council Election Forum

Harry Danilevics opening

A two hour Sedona City Council Election Forum was held at the Sedona Public Library on the evening of July 19, 2016, and sponsored by the League of Women Voters Greater Verde Valley and the Sedona Chamber of Commerce and Tourism Bureau.

Sedona AZ (July 21, 2016) –  On this past Tuesday evening of July 19, 2016, the League of Women Voters Greater Verde Valley (LWVGVV) and the Sedona Chamber of Commerce & Tourism Bureau hosted a live feed Sedona City Council Election Forum on Facebook (you can use the hash tag #LWVGVVFORUMS to search Google, Facebook & Twitter for posts related to the forum, or by clicking the Facebook icon on the bottom of Chamber’s website) with thanks to PR Manager Kegn Moorcroft for filming. The video will remain on the Facebook page until the day of the election.

Mary Chicoine was the evenings moderator and she opened with what the LWVGVV is all about; “The League of Women Voters is a nonpartisan political organization. Our mission is to encourage informed and active participation in government, work to increase understanding of major public policy issues, and influence public policy through education and advocacy.” The organization neither support nor oppose any candidate or political party. This forum was for City of Sedona City Council Candidates up for election, but the Mayor didn’t participate, as she is unopposed.

Our current mayor Sandy Moriarty was in attendance, as well as sitting Councilors Jon Thompson and Scott Jablow, but merely as spectators to the forum. All six of the candidates were arranged at the table from left to right in this order: Tom Lamkin, Joe Vernier, Jessica Williamson, John Currivan, John Martinez, and Gerhard Mayer. The purpose of the Election Forum was to freely inform and to educate ourselves on who is running to manage our local government.

Once again Gerhard Mayer and Tom Lamkin are vying for the two-year council seat, and John Currivan, Joe Vernier, Jessica Williamson, and John Martinez are all campaigning for the three available four-year council seats. Mayor Sandy Moriarty is running uncontested which means she will assume another two-year mayoral seat automatically.

Harry Danilevics opening 2

LWVGVV Sedona Election Forum candidates L to R: Tom Lamkin, Joe Vernier, Jessica Williamson, John Currivan, John Martinez and Gerhard Mayer

Each candidate was provided the opportunity to introduce themselves with a two-minute opening statement, where they were asked to address their reason for running, their qualifications, and what they see as the biggest challenge facing Sedona and how they would resolve it.

Tom Lamkin: “Hello, my name is Tom Lamkin, and I appreciate the opportunity to speak with you tonight. My goal is to hear what you have to say, and not what I have to say so much, but I want to know what your concerns are regarding Sedona, and I’ll do the best I can to address those. Just over four months ago I stepped forward to serve Sedona by asking Council for a chance to interview for the seat vacated by Angela LeFevre. There were others who also stepped forward to be considered, Mike Ward former Sedona City Councilor, Gerhard Mayer from Planning & Zoning also volunteered to be considered. After each of us had interviewed, the council debated whom to appoint to the position. My preparation must have impressed council, who after some discussion decided to appoint me as the interim councilor. I’d like to thank Mayor Moriarty, Councilor Thompson and Councilor Williamson for their votes that put me, Tom Lamkin, on the city council over the last four months. I’ve learned a great deal from the other councilors as well including Councilor Jablow and Councilor Martinez who welcomed me and provided guidance. My greatest challenge I found though in assuming the position wasn’t getting up to speed on the issues but rather developing my own personal philosophy of government. I had to decide how I would govern, and which principles I would follow. I’d like to thank past Vice Mayor Mark DiNunzio for that advice. I don’t mean to imply that our philosophies are the same, but I thankfully only learned that it’s better to question and to understand than it is to assume. My own philosophy is one based upon gathering information and input from all sources, including the citizen’s of Sedona. I support the principles that provide for fiscal responsibility and governing without becoming overly intrusive. I want to focus on the most important issues that have the most impact on citizens while keeping within their will. I ask that you consider me, Tom Lamkin, as your candidate of choice and vote for me to be your Councilor for the next two years, thank you.”

Joe Vernier: “Hello everybody, and I’d like to echo Councilor Lamkin’s appreciation for the League of Women Voters and The Chamber of Commerce for putting this forum together, and I’d also like to say thank you to all who are interested enough to come out here and hear from the candidates and our desire to serve you as the citizens here in Sedona. My name is Joe Vernier, I originally came here in 1999 and served as the Police Chief and retired from my job as a Police Chief in 2010. I wasn’t very successful at it at the time because Allen Everett the Mayor who hired me, initially, asked me to be his Deputy at the state liquor department, so I went and worked down in Phoenix for about five years. But I love this community, the people here, everything about Sedona, so much, that I couldn’t keep myself away from here, so I cam back up here, and I have lived, worked, and played here through all those years, and the one thing I want to do is be able to come back and give back all of the blessings that Sedona and the community and the citizens here have provided for me, my family, and my life, and to me serving on council is one great way to do that. And so again I thank all of you for your time being here and I would look forward to hopefully winning your vote, and I will do everything in my power not to win your vote but to earn your vote as a Councilor to keep your support serving as a Councilor for all of the people here in Sedona. Thank you.”

Jessica Williamson: “Hi, I’m Jessica Williamson and I’m running for reelection this year for the Sedona City Council. I’ve served on there for four years and I believe I’ve made a real and positive impact on the decisions that the council has made. The council tackled a lot of items this year, and during the time I served four years, some of them are; Council lead the fight to prevent Yavapai College from selling the Sedona campus and we’ve been working with the college to establish a culinary and hospitality program, and the college has put 3.5 million aside to do that, and OLLI remains. In order to accommodate the festivals and events held at Posse Grounds and other city venues, we passed an ordinance that allows beer and wine with those events with a permit from the city. We created a citizens engagement program that allows the city manager to establish working groups of citizens to research issues and come back to us with recommendations. We use time-share in lue funds to purchase the Historic Brewer Road Ranger Station Property and begin planning for a community park. Proof the design and construction of Barbara Antonsen Park and it’s under construction. We continue to accelerate drainage projects and we approved funding for our popular splash park for kids and a bike skills park. The coming years are gonna bring additional challenges that are going to require decisive and thoughtful action by the council. The council cannot put off making important decisions about traffic. It won’t be easy and it won’t be cheap to implement the recommendations from the study that’s currently under way. I am prepared to make those decisions, the decisions that need to be made for our community to improve traffic management. I’m dedicated, practical, and effective. I love Sedona and want to continue being be a part of ensuring its bright future.”

John Currivan: “Thank you and thank you all for being here. I’m John Currivan, my wife Pat and I were married here in Sedona 20 years ago and we love Sedona. We want to protect Sedona and in order to protect Sedona I believe we need a city council that does a better job listening to the people. And we need a city council that adheres to certain core principles that I believe in and those include limited government, they include protecting our freedom of choice, they also include fiscal responsibility. Let me tell you just a little bit about my own background because it’s a bit unusual, I started out studying engineering at Cornell University on a Navy ROTC scholarship and I went on and got a couple masters degrees after that. I went into the Navy and served as a Navy Jet Pilot, which means I got to do a lot of really fun things like landing on aircraft carriers, but then the navy sent me back to Cornell for law school to get a law degree and then I served in the JAG core as a Navy JAG lawyer and also as a judge. In private practice I had 28 years of experience as a tax lawyer with a global law firm, Jones Day, doing business planning for small businesses. And here in Sedona I was three years on the Sedona planning and zoning commission. I believe that our biggest problem that we face is probably the traffic problem, and we’ve all talked about it. I believe we can actually do something about it, there’s not a simple solution but it’s going to take some leadership. We’re gonna have to think about solutions outside the city limits, we’re gonna have to get the right people together, people from the county, from the village, from the forest service, but if we do that I believe we can actually come together and solve this very difficult problem. Thank you.”

John Martinez: “Good evening everybody, I want to thank the league of women voters, I want to thank Mary, Barbara for inviting everybody, and the Chamber. This is a unique set up that we got, I actually kind of like that. Obviously I want to make this very quick because I know we all want to go home and watch the National Republican Convention going on. So I’ll see if I can get through this very quickly. Four years ago I was blessed and humbled when the City of Sedona voted me to be on the Sedona City Council, which represents the city which is the greatest and most beautiful city, in my opinion and I think a lot of other people’s opinion, in the world. When I was elected I had no prior governmental experience but I did have many many years in accounting, forty years to be exact. I worked primarily in the private sector and I knew that I could bring that work ethic and experience to Sedona to make this thing run as smoothly as possible. I believe my biggest contribution in the four years that I’ve been here is to bring to life the whole budget process that we go through. Right now we are spending more than we are bringing in revenue. So we need to figure out how to address the needs of the community versus the wants of the community. And I believe that we need to partner even greater with the Sedona Chamber of Commerce, because to quote Jennifer, in the sense that “Sedona’s primary industry is tourism, and Sedona’s economic generator is tourism, therefore Sedona’s future is directly tied to tourism”. Yes, we have traffic problems, but I come from California, and if you’ve ever been there, those are traffic problems, but we’ve got a traffic study going on and the recommendations that they’re coming up with, we have the courage to implement them. Thank you very much.”

Gerhard Mayer: “Good evening, thank you very much to the hosts who gave us the opportunity to present ourselves. And I would like to start with me coming to this country, I was born on the Fourth of July in an American Army hospital in Germany after the Second World War. I was destined to come to this country. Parents moved to the southern Austria border of Italy and now Slovenia. We lived in a two-bedroom apartment shared with two other ladies. Occasionally a Cadbury chocolate was given to us kids by the British occupation forces. Mother lost her three brothers in the war and then lost the estate as well. Nothing left but our lives. I learned very early on to save when we had more than we needed for the not so good times. I learned also that we have met very hard times after the war being occupied for ten years. I met the love of my life here in Sedona, raised my children, and made a decent living for 33 years here in Sedona. So I’m passionate about the place I call my family’s home. But it takes more than passion; it also takes ability to serve the public well. Listening, government should not control the people, people should control the government. Values, character, honesty, leadership, and integrity, I definitely meet those criteria’s. Why I’m running, I’m very concerned about the present and future of Sedona. Tourism will be always our economic engine, it’s our lifeline. The destination-marketing plan of the Chamber of Commerce for 2017 might lead us to a more sustainable tourism. I understand and listen to all sides, having served for almost 8 years as a public servant on various Committees, Commissions, and currently Planning & Zoning Commission there is no lack of experience to serve as a councilor for the benefit of the entire community. Thank you.”

Next the candidates were asked to, again in two minutes, publicly answer a question that was given to them ahead of time, which was: 

 “In 2014 the lodging industry increased their bed tax in order to invest more in tourism, Sedona’s primary economic generator, do you support the 55% formula funding to the Chamber of Commerce & Tourism Bureau? Why or Why Not? And what do you think or feel are Sedona’s top three opportunities for economic diversity?”

Joe Vernier

Joe Vernier

Joe Vernier: “That’s a difficult question to answer whether I personally support it or not because that was a decision that was made between the Chamber and the lodging industry and their desire, and I think I understand the purpose behind that, because the fact that we had come out of a significant recession and we were trying to get Sedona operating again and one of the things I experienced after the year after I left, as a police chief, is there were actual layoffs in the city because the economy had declined so much, and just a personal aside on that, one of the people that was laid off was a police officer, subsequently got a brain tumor, and passed away. So he gets laid off, his income is reduced, his medical coverage is reduced, and so those kinds of things are devastating when they happen to individuals, so from that standpoint I can see the importance as to why we would want to have a vital economy here in Sedona. Three diversifications of economy, and this is not my area of expertise by a long shot, but I’m hoping that I will learn more and more from the experts in this particular field. Things I would consider to take a look at is what are the trends that are going out there. Yesterday I was talking to an insurance agent and the insurance agent was telling me that basically Millennials, the younger generations, are moving away form cars, and you have autonomous vehicles, and so as a result are there trends that we can consider for the future. I don’t know the exact answer, but I think that’s what we have to take a look at. So most of those are in fact technology, I know that we have a pretty significant robust medical economy around here and are there ways that we can bring more of that in Sedona, I think that’s something we should take a serious look at. We have a major shift in education and education as you know they’re combining and consolidating schools and so again I think there’s another opportunity for us to look at that as potential point of diversification.

Jessica Williamson

Jessica Williamson

Jessica Williamson: “Thank you, Mary, well I was on the Council and I voted for the additional bed tax and I was totally impressed that the industry that benefits from destination marketing and the chamber the most taxed themselves to pay for that, and I think that’s like a first in lot of ways. I think it provides a source of income, an additional source of income to the Chamber and to the City; the City shares the upside of the additional half tax. I think it was a good initiative and I think it will prove to be very useful in the future as well. Well I think that one of the big things is going to be home-based technology businesses. I think there is a big space, a big push for technological home businesses and I think when we get our broadband robust enough that will be able to take off. I also agree that the medical research and development is an area in which there is likely to be a lot of opportunity. I also think conferences and training here, for art, for a lot of different conference opportunity and training opportunities. Sedona has a draw that would make that a very lucrative proposition I think in the future. I also want to add at this point that one of the things that the chamber has done, this is a little off the topic, one of the things the chamber has done with some of the money that it had is it actually funded opportunities for managing tourism better. It’s doing brochures to get people to different parts of the trails that aren’t currently used as much, to get people off the main trails, they’ve put money aside for implementing some of traffic management.”

John Currivan

John Currivan

John Currivan: “First of all I want to say that I am in favor of development in Sedona. And I know a lot of people complain about the amount that is going to the chamber, it’s about $2 million in the budget this year, but first of all that figure of $2,000,000 includes about $275,000 that’s a carry over from last year, just to be fair, and also that money comes from the bed tax as I’m sure most of you understand that 55% of that goes to the chamber and it’s paid really by the visitors and the lodging industry and not by the Sedona tax payers. So if we were to cut out that 55% and eliminate the amount that goes to the chamber the city budget wouldn’t be any better off. It would just even out more or less. So, I’ve taken a look at the chambers latest marketing plan, actually I’ve read through it, and I think they are trying to address the problems that we are having. You know people say how much is enough, aren’t we bringing enough tourists into Sedona? I think that we recognize that we have peaks and valleys, and the chamber is really doing a good job trying to target the valleys and not the peaks. I hope they are successful in that regard but at least that’s what they are trying to do. They are also trying to target the day-trippers, you know day-trippers come in and they don’t spend very much money and they don’t spend the night, and therefore they don’t pay a bed tax but they certainly contribute to our traffic problem. So they are trying very hard to do that and they are trying also bring in small conference groups. There is one shadow over all of this though and that is our traffic problem. If we don’t solve our traffic problem we are going to actually harm our tourist industry. We hear anecdotal stories about people who say I am never coming back because of the traffic I encountered and all of that. So I don’t want to see that. I do support what we are doing but I want to solve the traffic problem. As far as expansion goes I would just quickly mention medical and aging in place.”

John Martinez

John Martinez

John Martinez: “Well, I can tell you right now two minutes isn’t enough, maybe three. But yes I was part of the council that voted to approve the 55% increase and in fact it goes back even further when I talk with Jennifer. They said I think we need to increase the bed tax because at that point, in my opinion, is that we are talking about the visitors coming here and it was mentioned before it would not affect the citizens directly with regard to a tax, and that’s what a lot of people don’t want. But I said they are the economic drivers, the chamber and the hotel lodging industry, so I said we can partner, that would be a perfect private public partnership to generate additional revenue for this city. It was a case of they increase the tax upon themselves which then was passed on to the visitors. What they are planning to do now and it was mentioned earlier, they have got an almost $400,000 product development budget to help the city in a number of ways, trails, and parking, and projects such as that. With regards to additional economic areas that we can advance here in the City of Sedona, the culinary, it was talked earlier, we got the school, we’re gonna have culinary and hospitality courses, that will definitely help the city with regards to it. We are gonna build, if we are gonna manage, the growth in the hotel industry here in Sedona we are going to need qualified people that are going to staff that. The City has just hired an economic development director, that will help start entrepreneurialship with regard to making new businesses in Sedona. It was also talked about, technology, in home technology; we are working on that with regards to the Internet, cell towers, and so on. So I think the future is bright for Sedona, yes we do think we have things to address, but I think it’s a good partnership between the Chamber and the City.

Gerhard Mayer

Gerhard Mayer

Gerhard Mayer: “I want to show you something. I have been here for 33 years and I have seen Sedona grow. I like the growth. I like sustainable growth.  And I talked to the previous director of tourism for Arizona and he gave me an article to read, “In Search of the Tourist Egg, Developers Killed the Goose.” When I talked to Jennifer about the issue of over development and where are we gonna go, and I wrote several articles in several papers in regards of the quality vs. quantity and when we talk about quality, L’Auberge was at the time, I was associated with the people who developed L’Auberge, L’Auberge put Sedona on the map, on the global map I would say. Alright, and I am also a very creative person, I think and come up with ideas and come up with solutions as well. And I have talked about the improvement projects of our economy, and this is a paper I wrote in 2011, I said, “More resorts like the Enchantment within the city limits brand Sedona as a spa, wellness, resort destination.” Culinary institute, I wrote that 1999, and presented it to the Yavapai College, so I am way ahead of the curve. I would like to see a hotel academy by any tourism school, international art academy, with diplomas, office clusters, shared conference rooms, sustainability campus, all ADU facilities, everything else I can explain to you at the table if you’re interested. Thank you.”

Tom Lamkin

Tom Lamkin

Tom Lamkin: “Thank you. I will tell you two years ago when I ran for city council I was for the bed tax and the 55% number. I don’t know what the right number is, but I pledge to you tonight, that when the revenues exceed $100,000,000 and they get $55,000,000 I will look into it further. Sedona is a vital tourist economy, we all benefit from the beauty of the red rocks, and it draws millions of visitors to our city every year, but along with those benefits also come the downside of our success. The consequences of that follow; traffic that’s been mentioned, over crowding of our amenities, and stressing of our infrastructure. We take steps to preserve our trails and neighborhoods and we wonder what can be done better to balance the city and the impact that is happening. There must be some way to balance the wants of the tourists with the needs of the citizens. I believe that the efforts of our destination marketing partner, The Chamber of Commerce division of Tourism, is already working to address this by readjusting its target markets. Renewed emphasis on targeting smaller groups, like the recent biking event is a good example of how Sedona can enjoy more events spread throughout the year with smooth revenue streams that help businesses remain more sustainable and have less impact on the community. We also looked at other resources, it’s been mentioned about Yavapai College, and with businesses we talked about culinary, we talked about maybe we can expand and include wine segments in the wine industry, maybe we should look at high tech and incubators, for cybersecurity, that’s an area that really is growing, can be protecting and can offer jobs. Yavapai College recently announced that the unmanned aerial system known as drones can be certified through their organization. Who knows where drones will lead in Sedona, not saying we want any of them flying around but its something to look into. We have also have to involve businesses as well, I’m excited the city is soon to have a new Director of Economic Development that can work in ways to forge partnerships between the city and private enterprises in Sedona. The recent artists and residents program taking place in the Village of Oak Creek may be considered that we might be able to do the same thing for business. Hosting small businesses for entering or training opportunities might be willing to bring new services to Sedona.”

After opening introductions and answer the question regarding the 55% funding formula and top three opportunities for economic diversity, the candidates speed networked where they had ten minutes to spend at each of the six tables in the room. The discussion would move around providing the ability to interact with each of the candidates for some time where individuals were.

By 8:10 p.m., the candidates were back in the front of the room and were asked to share in one minute’s time “something they had learned in going around the tables, or was there something that you heard that you haven’t heard before”:

Jessica Williamson: “I want to start by saying, I am so weird, I must be a geek, because this is the most fun I’ve had in quite a long time, and I thank everybody for being so interesting and so interactive and so polite and listening to my answers and I really appreciate all that. I didn’t really hear things I hadn’t heard before, I did hear an agreed emphasis on sustainability from a number of people which I really understood and I appreciated hearing that as an emphasis going forward. People are very interested, as everybody here I know is, in traffic. People seem to understand the limitations in what could and couldn’t be done. I’ve just appreciated everybody’s asking intelligent and reasonable questions, and listening to what I had to say. I think you guys are all great.”

John Currivan: “Well I certainly enjoyed it, I thought I got a lot of really good questions. Everybody was engaged, they were all paying attention, they all had things on their minds. I found an awful lot of people wanted to hear about the trash issue, which I hadn’t gotten a chance to talk about before and so I did get a chance to share my thoughts on that with everybody. For the most part things that I heard are things that I had come across before. There was once point that one of the gentleman made about the level of recycling in Sedona, which is a little bit different than I thought, so he’s going to send me a study on that, and I’ll be looking forward to reading it. Other than that it was just a great experience, thank you.”

John Martinez: “This whole thing was just an experience and I really enjoyed it, and at some point Jessica said “I didn’t know how the thing was supposed to be”; Speed Dating! One thing I think everybody should applaud themselves for a good turnout and great questions. But, I, the really thing that I, I mean I knew we have a very educated and studious and engaged citizenship here in the city of Sedona, and this proved it. I mean you had great questions, and I got put on the spot sometimes, and sometimes I just said I don’t know, I’ll have to come back and respond to that. But one of the things that was something that I don’t know is that the homeless problem. Someone said we got a homeless problem, issue, here in Sedona so I got to find out if we do. Thank you.”

Gerhard Mayer: “Well, this was a format I really liked. I didn’t like the first part because two minutes is not enough; I get three minutes at city council to talk. So one thing. The questions I was facing were all legit, all well thought through, and I have to apologize that my passion sometimes runs a little while, everybody said I’m crazy to run for this, and maybe I am. I admit that the topics I was facing from the audience were a little bit out of specialty, the sustainability part, where I was plastered with if I was for trash hauling or not, so I think I did my best I could, and I tell you problem solving skills, creativity, and thinking outside of the box are my strengths. Thank you very very much. Vote for me please, thank you.”

Tom Lamkin: “Well we talked about a lot so I appreciate your time. I can’t say that I hadn’t heard about the issues before because a lot of the same ones come up, you’re all concerned about some of the same issues. The ones that I had in my groups pretty much were small town feel (how to prepare it, keep it), budget balance (what would you do to increase it, decrease it), posse grounds events (don’t mess with them, have that campout, keep the pumpkin fest), traffic, economic development, property tax came up I know I hear that one pretty often, but trash, Tlaquepaque North and possible traffic issues there. The thing that struck me most though was affordable housing and it was pointed out that there may be some restrictions or ordinances on how we can implement something like that here and I think that’s key for us in the future, so I’ll be looking into that. Thank you.”

Joe Vernier: “I believe the most significant thing that I learned while I was out there doing this, I guess you can call it speed dating, I never dated like this. But the most significant thing I learned is everyone that’s here really cares about Sedona, and the community, and are very passionate about the things that they care about. In my meetings with the groups out here pretty much the same things, issues pertaining to budget, probably one of the biggest ones was the challenge to sustainability of our economy, yet at the same time for the people who live here what are the quality of life challenges that go with it. Part of that involves traffic. The trash thing, was very interesting, because still a lot of opposition but apparently I was offered some information to take another look at that so I’ll see what that information is and I guess I’m done. Thank you.”

American FlagThe last section, which ended the evening, was the two-minute closing statement each candidate was allowed:

Gerhard Mayer: “Again, I am a person who is very passionate about this community and I’d like future generations to have the same quality of life here as I have currently and to aim for this goal we’re going have to be a little bit more concerned of which way we are going to grow. And if we’re going to grow smart or if we’re going to go with anything goes, and I would say if we are smart we are going to be providing for future generations and that’s very important in every way you can think of. Economically, environmentally, and the beauty of Sedona and the surrounding area will maintain its current state. So that’s what I’d like to see, is we maintain, improve, and that it’s important for it be improved. And quality like I said before at the tables supersedes quantity and that’s what I think our emphasis should be all about. Thank you very much. Vote for me if you want to have an honest, straight talking, very passionate, and loving, Sedona loving person, on the city council. You will be delighted to have me on there. Thank you.”

John Martinez: “I think all of us love this city. That’s why we moved here and that’s why we still live here. And I’ve tried to represent the whole city when I ran for council, and I know that everyone’s not going to agree with my beliefs for the city of Sedona, but I don’t represent the loudest groups in the city, I have to think of all of Sedona. And I believe my decisions in my heart and in my mind are what I’m doing for the best of the city based on best practices that I’ve learned from people like you that have spoken to me in other areas. They do work, and a lot of people say well just because something is broken we shouldn’t do it. I know there’s a lot of business owners in here that says even if it’s not broke, if it can’t be improved, it should be addressed. When I ran for council four years ago I never promised that I would fix every issue that would be presented, but I did say I would address it. So, there might be some candidates here that’ll say, “I will fix it, I will fix it”, well, as they say, be aware of strangers bearing gifts. We, all of us, all of us want your vote, but if you don’t agree with what I believe in, then don’t vote for me, but vote for somebody. We’ve got a lot of talented people on here and I’m gonna say is that for the last two elections that I’ve been interested in, we’ve got basically like 6,000 registered voters in the City of Sedona and only about 2,500 people vote. That’s horrible. So if you don’t believe what I’m in get off the couch and vote for somebody. As I’ve always said, if you’re not a part of the solution, then maybe you’re a part of the problem. Once again to the league of women voters, and thank you to the chamber. Thank you.”

John Currivan: “Everything that we do has to be for the best interest of the City of Sedona. It’s for us, and it’s for future generations. And every decision we make has to be done in that spirit. So when an issue comes up, the people that you elect have to look at it in that way and when you elect somebody you have to know what they stand for. We know what the issues are today. We know about traffic, and trash, you could name a dozen others I suppose. But what we don’t know is what is going to be next years hot issue, what’s gonna be a hot issue in the year after that. You are electing people to four-year terms, you need to know what they stand for, and I told you some of my core beliefs when I was speaking earlier. I believe in limited government, that is if we don’t need to get the government involved in something, like for example trash hauling, I think we should not get the government involved. We need to respect the people’s freedom of choice. If people have a, I’ll use trash hauling again just as an example, if people have a choice when it comes to something like that, why should the government take it away from them. And we need to be fiscally responsible; we need to look not only at what our current budget looks like, but what the trends are and where we are heading in order to make sure that tax dollars are spent responsibly. So with that in mind I ask that you just take into account not only how people stand on today’s issues, but also what their core values are so you’ll know how they approach tomorrow’s issues. Thank you.”

Jessica Williamson: “This process tonight really made me realize how much I like being involved in actively considering and talking and thinking about the issues that all of you raised tonight and all of the issues that I have faced over the past four years. It is really exciting for me and I just would like to do this every week but I think you know what I stand for because I’ve been on council four years and I have four years of voting record. It’s not a mystery. I’m practical, I’m decisive, and I can see what the issues really are. I try not to get distracted by all the stuff that floats around every issue that we talk about. Council made a lot of decisions over the past four years and I am really proud of the contribution I have made toward those decisions. But I know people don’t agree with me 100% of the time, some people don’t agree with me ever, and some people agree with me most of the time and some of the stuff they don’t agree with. That’s to be expected. I am not a one-issue voter and I don’t think most people are but I have approached every issue purposefully, and very consciously, to act in a way I believe is in the best interest of all of Sedona. Even the people who don’t vote. Even the people who don’t participate. I am elected to represent everybody and that is what I try to do. I do have a website and I’ve written a bunch of articles and posted issue papers on it. So if anybody wants to know more about how I think and what I think you can go there, and pick and choose. I’ve been effective and I’ve been responsible on city council, I understand the issues, and I think we need a council that’s decisive. That would be me. Vote for me.”

Joe Vernier: “I guess the best I can offer is my intent on council, is to be a representative who uses good judgment and common sense to get the job done that is required on council. And also a significant part of that is hearing your thoughts and feelings and concerns out there and one of the groups I shared with this and that when I was a police chief here, and kind of half joking but there’s also some seriousness on this, during my eleven years as police chief I said there’s a lot of great people, a lot of talent here, in Sedona, and I said I have more unpaid consultants than any police chief in the United States. But I think tapping that talent that we have out here, I think a lot of the representation of that talent is sitting right out here in this room, is a critical piece for me to be able to successfully serve as councilperson. I would ask for your involvement, I have an individual flier in the back with email and a website, that I’d welcome any contact from anybody out there. Please, I’ve been in this community for a long time and a lot of you know me for a long time, please feel free to contact me and ask any question that you want. I’ll do my best to give you an honest answer. I think the one thing ill say is that I was in law enforcement for forty-one years. I had success in everything I did, I maintained my integrity, I ran a good organization, I’m proud of all that we have accomplished, and it wasn’t me, it was the people that I worked with and I have to look at it from the same point serving as a councilor, it’s not going to be about me, it’s going to be about serving you. I believe the servant is government and it’s my job to serve you, and I hope that I can serve you effectively, and always do the right thing at the right time for the right reasons.”

Tom Lamkin: “Thank you, again I’d like to thank you for your time this evening. I felt that the meetings at each table was a great way to get a variety of information that is important to you. We’ve already talked about several of the issues, I won’t go through those again, but I will be looking into them. I appreciate your willingness to be open and honest, what you think is being done right and what you think needs a little bit of improvement. Help us work on council, I ask you to help get me back on council and retain me there. I’m gonna be your councilor for another four months before the election kicks in with the new people, I hope I’m one of them. I still have a lot to learn and understand, I feel that things are getting better, and with your continued help can stay focused. I encourage you to take advantage of the Citizens Engagement Program, little picture of Lauren Browne here who is the coordinator for that at the city. Get on the website, continue to provide your information, we need your input. I’d love to see all of you at the next council meeting. I think it’d be great but watch on the internet if nothing else. I think it’s a great way for you to provide input, especially if you don’t attend one of the sessions, if you’re working, or unable to meet with us. You can find it, great city website by the way, second only to Los Angeles according to what I read recently, but for a small city it’s an unbelievable website. I encourage you to stay involved, and contact any of the city councilors through email, phone, we do read your notes and I’m willing to meet with you to discuss anything further. Call me, I like to talk as you can imagine and my wife was grateful she got a break this evening from me talking to her. Thank you very much for helping with that. So when you think, give me a call or send me an email, you got my card, and I want to thank you. I’ll be glad to talk with any group that you want to assemble or individual meeting, because Lamkin listens. I want to hear what you have to say and represent it on council. Please vote for Tom Lamkin. You’ll notice on the ballot on the very bottom I’m running for the two-year term not the four-year term and vote for that first name, Tom Lamkin, thank you.”

This SedonaEye.com article written by Harry Danilevics.

Read www.SedonaEye.com for daily news and interactive views!

Read www.SedonaEye.com for daily news and interactive views!

113 Comments

  1. Ted says:

    Will vote Joe Vernier and John Currivan. Maybe Mayer. Will decide when know more. Best coverage of local politicians. I liked you let their voices be heard without editorializing. You covered this sooner and better than the Red Rock News. Congratulations for beating #1 upstart #2. Guess the 20something got it right folks.

  2. Eddie S. Maddock says:

    Before someone boxes my ears (or something) the following remark addressing a comment made by @@Mary C under a previous article by Harry Danilevics more appropriately addresses the forum reviews disclosed in this article. So for clarification relating to council candidates’ positions, the comment is duplicated here.

    @@Mary C says:
    July 22, 2016 at 3:54 PM
    Here we go again. Why include my name in your comment when so far I’ve remained unattached to this amazing review of the Candidate’s Election Forum as reported by Harry Danilevics.

    However, apparently you are unaware that neither the Fire District nor the School District are under the jurisdiction of incorporated City of Sedona. So maybe it is you in need of a cup of coffee or something with the Fire Chief or to attend a School Board Meeting in order to brush up on your own deficiency in knowledge.

    As for the city council election, based on the above review of the forum, it appears that regardless which person doesn’t make the cut, basically nothing will change and it will be business as usual.

    Good luck to all candidates.

    Eddie Maddock

  3. Bob, uptown says:

    LWV has credibility, LWVGVV lacks it. Why’s that?

  4. @Bob, uptown says:

    “LWV has credibility, LWVGVV lacks it. Why’s that?”

    Could it be because of the current President, Barbara Litrell, true blue left-winger and impeccably politically correct? It’s little wonder they united with the Chamber of Commerce since B. Litrell was one of the main cheerleaders to get them the forever contract, allegedly for advertising. Wonder how much the C of C spent to co-sponsor this forum and what was the source of the money?

  5. Jay D says:

    How convenient. The Chamber of Commerce co-sponsors this event and the first question to the candidates is about whether or not they will support the annual city contract with them, presently with a price tag of over two million dollars annually? Wow talk about a stacked deck.

    Then to top it off of course none of them spoke against it. No surprise. That would have been immediate political suicide although there are only six of them. However what did come as a surprise was this attitude that because the lodging industry collects the bed tax they, via the Chamber of Commerce, are entitled to keep it! Yep – that’s the gist of it.

    Now based on that questionably logical deduction, why is it that every other business in Sedona that collects state, county, and city sales taxes aren’t entitled to keep it? And in the case of utility companies add a franchise fee. Why aren’t they entitled to keep that as well? After all – THEY are collecting it!

    Now it’s very interesting how the subject of the city financed “Visitors Center” (also labeled Sedona Chamber of Commerce Visitors Center) wasn’t included in the discussion. How do any of these candidates feel about the several hundred thousand dollars of city taxes (besides bed tax) fund that operation which ONLY refers and represents CHAMBER MEMBERS!!!

    Any city business (and they do exist) that prefers to decline membership to an alleged “non-profit” special interest association is shunned, even though they, in fact, contribute financially to this asinine scenario. Applying the same non-rational thinking then, those non-member businesses should not be required to collect taxes – any of them.

    What’s next? Will the Sedona City Limits signs soon be altered to indicate now entering “City of Sedona Regional Chamber of Commerce?”

    Arizona Liberty, are you paying attention?

  6. Kayra says:

    What’s FB saying?

  7. Ray says:

    good read

  8. Mary C says:

    As the entire candidate slate has stated they support Tourism and the Chamber of Commerce above residents, I suggest we boycott this election. Why participate when you vote does not matter?

  9. Summation says:

    In a word, here’s what this Sedona Candidates Forum was: RIGGED.
    Sound familiar?
    Shame on Greater Verde Valley Chapter of the League of Woman Voters for allowing this to happen. Very bad for the League of Woman Voters nationally, as is the rogue Chamber of Commerce being allowed to control Sedona.

    Wise up, people. You are being HAD.

  10. Who Would Have Thought? says:

    It would be interesting to know just how many people are still around since Sedona incorporated (besides Sandy Moriarty and James Eaton) and of the remaining, how many (besides Sandy and James) are pleased with what has happened to Sedona during these years after it was approved. Of course, many left – some to other states like Pat & Dr. Keaton, Gloria Sherman, Spencer/Evelyn Thompson, and others such as Patti/Ron Henry, Ann/Bob Seibel moved to VOC – just to mention a few stalwart supporters that couldn’t stand it here after realizing the mistake. (sorry about spelling of names if I goofed) Others, of course, have since passed on.

    Anyhow, point being, that to think the end result of this fiasco has turned into a complete total sell-out to the people who really believed incorporation would save and protect the small town and scenic qualities that attracted us in the first place.

    Instead the present day sell-out to a regional Chamber of Commerce that should rightfully be declared the black sheep of the National Chamber of Commerce Assn. for disgracing the purpose of their existence (IMO).

    Please, Arizona Liberty, appeal to our state legislators to conduct a full investigation into this apparent contrived situation which is given further substantiation by this most recent candidate’s forum, forcing participants publicly to declare their uncompromised support for maintaining this special interest, member driven, allegedly non-profit organization as the go-to place for every single decision being made not only in incorporated Sedona but the entire Verde Valley, which impacts quality of life from health, safety, and beneficial welfare aspects to residents and tourists alike.

    This is wrong! The Chamber manipulated the election two years ago and things have only gotten worse. In your face take it or leave it is the message being sent to the lowly flatlanders – worse than treatment befalling recognized minorities across the country.

    How about a new movement: “Sedona Residents Matter”

    Short of an authentic outside audit of both the City and Chamber of Commerce, in addition to charges that will effectively discontinue state funding to Sedona until they are forced to clean up their act, it will never happen.

    In the meantime it’s probably safe to say the “chamber” is busy cooking their books to cover up where all that money is really going besides ads on Arizona Channel 3! (to bring in destination tourists from where? Yuma?)

  11. Ray C. Parrish says:

    Ray C. Parrish
    2016 Green Party Candidate for Congress in District One of Arizona, Entrepreneur, Musician
    Vernon, Az. · http://raycparrishforstaterepresentative.blogspot.com/
    is following SedonaEye.com!

  12. SB 1487 state law says:

    For sometime Sedona City Councilors have manipulated control to enable those outside the incorporated city limits to benefit, control and spend taxpayers money on special interest groups that have nothing to do with the responsibility of a city.

    During this they have used every underhanded tactic to suppress anyone that has tried to stop this. Many of the councilors have had a conflict of interests and have reached outside their jurisdiction by doing so. Our city employees report to the CC and therefore must do as the CC directs them.

    Pasted from the City of Sedona website “About The City Manager-
    The City of Sedona functions under a Council-Manager form of government in which the City Manager is appointed by the Mayor and City Council and reports directly to the elected officials.”

    They have enabled special interest groups to participate in city business when they do not reside in the city limits. Via Citizens engagements, committees and other groups. The requirement of being a city resident has been removed by the CC.

    Now the state of Arizona has recognized that we have too many rogue cities and passed SB 1487. This was done to control them and protect you. Take five minutes and think about all the injustices imposed on the residents and businesses. Think of all the confusion of jurisdiction and city responsibility. Many people feel the chamber is part of the city. They are not and they should not be receiving one cent. The lodging council a sub group of the chamber is not exclusive to the city limits and is not in the position to suggest any increase in taxes as they are not the ones paying it, most of their members are outside the city limits.

    Read up on this by reading this article https://sedonaeye.com/arizona-takes-a-necessary-right-turn

    It is up to us to insist that the CC go back to why we became incorporated. Enough of this insane self acclaimed power. The State of Arizona will start to inforce the state laws.

    Senator Sylvia Tenney Allen
    President Pro Tempore
    602-926-5409
    1700 W. Washington
    Phoenix, AZ 85007

  13. SB 1487 state law says:

    PS The senator’s address is included in post so that you can write her.

  14. Sound Familiar? says:

    Even though Sedona supposedly doesn’t function under the “strong-mayor” type government, the following excerpt provided by League of Arizona Cities & Towns certainly rings a bell and makes one wonder at what point a “greased pathway” does, in fact, qualify as corruption:

    In a December 6, 2009, story in the Baltimore Sun headlined, “City’s governmental structure encourages official corruption,” reporter David B. Levy writes: “It is clear that developers and other interest groups perceive—probably correctly—that the best method to gain decisions in their favor is to ‘grease’ the pathway. Sometimes that grease is pure corruption. More frequently, it is some version of interest peddling that does not quite rise to the level of outright corruption. Either way, it bends governmental decisions away from the public interest and toward the private interest of those doing the greasing.” He goes on to say, “The best-managed and cleanest local governments in the United States are not strong-mayor governments; they are councilmanager governments.”

    http://www.azleague.org/ArchiveCenter/ViewFile/Item/199

    Repeat: “. . . some version of interest peddling that does not quite rise to the level of outright corruption. Either way, it bends governmental decisions away from the public interest and toward the private interest of those doing the greasing.”

    And even with a weak mayor form of government this clearly exists.

    Sedona in a nutshell?

  15. @SB 1487 state law says:

    Where can I go to order a sheet cake now that Cake Lady no longer has a store front?

  16. SB 1487 state law says:

    Correction Base of page

    For sometime Sedona City Councilors have manipulated control to enable those outside the incorporated city limits to benefit, control and spend taxpayers money on special interest groups that have nothing to do with the responsibility of a city.

    During this they have used every underhanded tactic to suppress anyone that has tried to stop this. Many of the councilors have had a conflict of interests and have reached outside their jurisdiction by doing so. Our city employees report to the CC and therefore must do as the CC directs them.

    Pasted from the City of Sedona website “About The City Manager-
    The City of Sedona functions under a Council-Manager form of government in which the City Manager is appointed by the Mayor and City Council and reports directly to the elected officials.”

    They have enabled special interest groups to participate in city business when they do not reside in the city limits. Via Citizens engagements, committees and other groups. The requirement of being a city resident has been removed by the CC.

    Now the state of Arizona has recognized that we have too many rogue cities and passed SB 1487. This was done to control them and protect you. Take five minutes and think about all the injustices imposed on the residents and businesses. Think of all the confusion of jurisdiction and city responsibility. Many people feel the chamber is part of the city. They are not and they should not be receiving one cent. The lodging council a sub group of the chamber is not exclusive to the city limits and is not in the position to suggest any increase in taxes as they are not the ones paying it, most of their members are outside the city limits.

    Read up on this by reading this article https://sedonaeye.com/arizona-takes-a-necessary-right-turn

    It is up to us to insist that the CC go back to why we became incorporated. Enough of this insane self acclaimed power. The State of Arizona will start to inforce the state laws.

    PLEASE WRITE
    Senator Sylvia Tenney Allen
    President Pro Tempore
    602-926-5409
    1700 W. Washington
    Phoenix, AZ 85007

  17. Mark says:

    If you do not take an interest in the affairs of your government, then you are doomed to live under the rule of fools.- Plato

  18. Jordan says:

    When the first question out of the box to this slate of candidates is about whether or not this city will continue a questionable $2.1 million dollar contract with the chamber of commerce – a contract without benefit of RFP’s or legitimate audit, well, it almost takes ones breath away! THAT’S the top critical issue in Sedona?
    State legislators: Either cut off funding to the city of Sedona or maybe you too would like to help support this regional special interest group with money from Arizona state taxpayers across the board. This is ridiculous!

    @Mark – you and Plato said a mouthful. Thanks for sharing.

  19. West Sedona Dave says:

    Yes Jordan,
    I would say that most here are completely out of touch!…So many are upset at the city for 2.1 million dollars aimed at tourism..
    For some reason the believe its stealing there tax money, which is a overreach…But Im not surprised in the least.

    They ignore that the State of Arizona does the same thing, and some of that money comes out of there general fund( go figure hea?)
    This years budget for the Arizona dept of tourism is a whopping 28 million, and 7.1 million out of the general budget!!!

    They pick and choose there outrage, sad actually…..

    http://www.bizjournals.com/phoenix/news/2016/01/15/no-cuts-or-increases-for-arizona-tourism-office-in.html

  20. A Suggestion says:

    When we write Senator Sylvia Allen, please remember–

    According to the “Campaign Finance Reports” on the City Clerk’s web pages, David Harkey, Partner at Owens Harkey in Phoenix, contributed $1,000.00 to Sandy Moriarty’s 2014 election campaign, and Steve Segner contributed $1,600.00.

    Owens Harkey is the advertising firm the Chamber of Commerce hired with City of Sedona taxpayer funds.

  21. @West Sedona Dave says:

    Did you even read the article Steve @West Sedona Dave? The state OWNS it dummy. They cut the budget and reduced their spending. Guess what the state doesn’t ADVERTISE Utah or California with the money. But that is EXACTLY what you do 100% of ALL Sedona City is supposed to STAY in the city limits.

    Try and slow down Steve and think it through. We all know you are dyslexic.

    The STATE owns it, promotes the exclusive state with a very small portion of the taxes they get. YOU went and asked for more to PROMOTE the REGION>>>>>

    This is why people DREAM that J. Rick would punch you out. Because you don’t tell the truth and are abusing the system. How does it feel to be the most hated person (you and jennifer) by the real Sedona’s PEOPLE?
    REMEMBER Arizona doesn’t use the taxes to market California, vegas or utah but we all know take many come through our state on the way there.

    Yep barf is perfect description.

  22. Larry A says:

    What makes it ok for the city to spend taxpayers money 2.01 this year alone for the regional chamber? What don’t you get? The CHamber is NOT a division of the city moron.
    2.01 for a tiny town of less than 10,000!!!!!!! $35,000 a week is being funneled to the regional chamber so that Steve and his buddies outside the city limit can save some bucks.
    They only bring in day trippers. Think people the chamber is NOT part of the City, Their member are OUTSIDE the city limits. @ steve segner @ WestSedona Dave

  23. @A Suggestion says:

    Please share with all of us on SE how those contributions are illegal????

  24. West Sedona Dave says:

    “Did you even read the article Steve @West Sedona Dave? The state OWNS it dummy. They cut the budget and reduced their spending. Guess what the state doesn’t ADVERTISE Utah or California with the money. But that is EXACTLY what you do 100% of ALL Sedona City is supposed to STAY in the city limits.”
    ———————————————————————————————————-
    May you please show me where that is a law?

    ———————————————————————————————————-

    City of Scottsdale AZ.
    About Us
    SCOTTSDALE CVB OVERVIEW
    The Scottsdale Convention & Visitors Bureau is a 501(c)(6) nonprofit, private company
    that has contracts with the City of Scottsdale and Town of Paradise Valley to conduct
    destination marketing efforts on behalf of these municipalities. Combined, these entities
    provided approximately $10.0 million of the CVB’s $12.9 million budget in 2014-15.
    The CVB’s primary source of revenue comes from bed tax collected by Scottsdale resorts
    and hotels and passed along to the City. Half of bed-tax collections come to the CVB for
    destination marketing, while the other half is invested by the City, including $1.5 million
    in bed-tax revenue that goes annually to the general fund. The City’s Tourism Development
    Commission (TDC) recommends to the Scottsdale City Council how to allocate the City’s
    remaining half of the bed-tax revenue, which is designated primarily for tourism-related
    capital projects and special events. The City’s relationship with the CVB is overseen by
    the City’s Tourism & Events Department and the TDC.
    ——————————————————————————————————–

    Are you aware that the city of Scottsdale also puts money up for there local events?

    Are you aware that the city of Phoenix also does this?

    You just keep overreaching, and are Ill informed….Im sorry, Im just trying to help you grasp how non-profits work with local governments all the time to boost revenues, help the tax base, and grow a tourist industry…

    OHY!

  25. West sedona resident says:

    @west Sedona DAVE

    Dave just to let you know…. Most of the comments posted above are the same person posting under different names….they think your someone else cause it’s hurts their EGO when someone has a different opinion then them…you know they can’t look beyond their own HATE

    Hope that helps

  26. @West Sedona Dave says:

    Thank you so very much @West Sedona Dave! You have in your own post proven /that the city of Sedona should not be gifting a regional lodging group.

    Your dyslexia proves it again in your post “The Scottsdale Convention & Visitors Bureau is a 501(c)(6) nonprofit, private company
    that has contracts with the City of Scottsdale and Town of Paradise Valley to conduct destination marketing efforts on behalf of these municipalities.”

    Did you even read it Steve? It is a Coap! Go ahead and call them, the hotels don’t pay to be listed. Then look again cause NO other lodging groups are PERMITTED under hotels if their municipalities do not contribute.

    But you are even more wrong if you think that Scottsdale gives their tourism to a chamber. Those that partake in regional tourism ALL pay to play.

    The city of Scottsdale has their own in house “Tourism and Events Department” and a exclusive “Tourism Development Commission” http://www.scottsdaleaz.gov/tourism http://www.scottsdaleaz.gov/Asset58515.aspx
    Read about it for yourself.

    You really are barf Steve. Not one city you claim pays for groups or businesses OUTSIDE the incorporated city LIMITS.

    Go back to your first post the State of Arizona doesn’t market CALIFORNIA, UTAH.
    Just because you grease the wheels to get the uneducated CC in doesn’t make it legally right. By you money grabbing money that does NOT belong to your regional group you breed hate…….. Can’t wait to see J.Rick (deleted by editor) you!

    Thanks again for the laugh. You really are a dyslexic joker………

  27. West S resident says:

    @i see thru you

    You really need to do a character profile on the person promoting actually bodily harm against another person if your really concerned about someone becoming unhinged…..

    Or are you really a self-serving BS artist that is actually the one promoting violence…

    I believe the later is most likely….. Get some help and call that number you posted…..really!!

  28. West Sedona Dave says:

    Who ever in the world you are…..get a grip…

    On one hand people complain about having to be a member to the chamber….Thats one point.( to collect a bed tax does not matter what hotel or if your a member)

    On another hand some think the 2.1 million is “our” tax money and shouldnt be spent. ( wrong its a bed tax on visitors it does not come out of our pockets and we do see some money to the regular fund)

    Then the complaints about either day trips or vacationers?…..Now I hate to break it to you but Sedona, and the rest of the Verde Valley are vacation destinations…..What that means is our economy is based on tourism!

    And then more tourist, the more the traffic……

    Sedona is doing a traffic study (by law) to see what there options are…..So next on the list will me alternate routs….

    Just wait till the city wants to put a street right through someone home to alleviate traffic congestion on 89a or 179…

    I can just imagine all the complainers coming out of the wood work….

    You see, You always find fault and never offer any solutions……

    Ive been reading hear for years……I finally decided to point out so many of these haters that live, and breath here….

    Im still waiting for your “so called law” that the city is violating!

    I could care less about garbage removal! .. I could care less what the Chamber does with 2 million dollars……I could care less about traffic……

    You see I have a good life, some medical problems and I spend my time trying to heal and get better……I dont hate….Im not vile, I dont threaten to punch, hurt or shoot people…

    Maybe eventually you will see I try to shine light into some of these dark corners that are self made and unfounded?

    If the city is doing wrong, and the Chamber is looting, hiding, or some other form of deviate plot against us……There day will come and we will have all the info through transparency…..Until then I will see other citys and towns trying to bring tourist to there home towns…..Sedona is doing there part, and use the chamber.

    I am sorry, no matter what I write, or what the city does, you will never be happy!

  29. Steve segner says:

    Hu mm, not me posting dave called your bluff, he had the facts , $12,900,000
    Scottsdale ….when and if I post it will be using my name not like most of the posters on this site.
    Steve

  30. @West Sedona Dave says:

    Public funding of private enterprise is the issue. Read your post. The state of Arizona doesn’t advertise California. (because they drive through or stop to buy a slice a pizza on their way) The City of Scottsdale doesn’t pay to advertise Paradise Valley.

    The City of Scottsdale has it own in house department for “Tourism and Events Department” and a exclusive “Tourism Development Commission” http://www.scottsdaleaz.gov/tourism http://www.scottsdaleaz.gov/Asset58515.aspx
    They only equally partake in a co-op with Paradise Valley and a few Indian Reservations.

    The city of Sedona is an incorporated area. PERIOD not a regional county.

    The lodging and chamber are private enterprises. Pay for your own advertising.
    Your ridiculous statements and lies are all intended to confuse people.

    Those in the tourist industry should form a fair Transient Bed District or Regional club. Where every member pays their own way. You can easily charge your customers a “Resort Fee” and pool those dollars together to advertise the region. The taxpayers should NOT pay for your advertising you and the region Steve. The city of Sedona has enough things to work on. One is the negative spending. They spend more than the bring in.

    Enough BS Dave – Steve. The BUSINESSES in the incorporated city limits bring in the sales tax and bed tax. NOT anyone else. Those taxes are intended to be used for the incorporated city PERIOD!

    Here is a challenge. If you and your regional Chamber are that great, then just go do it! Go create a fair system that everyone “Pays to Play”

    Meanwhile I will enjoy watching Rick and the Liberty Group “taking you down” from stealing. The residents and businesses in the incorporated City of Sedona deserve better.

    PS the in city hotels didn’t VOTE for your scam of stealing taxpayers money.

  31. Who cares? says:

    “I am sorry, no matter what I write, or what the city does, you will never be happy!” so writes West Sedona Dave. Who asked you for advice anyhow? If you are so ill then getting your knickers in such a twist because others think differently surely can’t be helping your condition.

    Chill out, man!

  32. Susan P says:

    Since the city of sedona is paying for all the marketing for the region I think it’s only fair that those benefitting start to pay their own way. It isn’t right that some businesses have to collect taxes and those outside don’t. When you think it through those that bring in the tourists cost our city more that those that don’t. I can’t get around town on the weekends. Shouldn’t they pay more?

  33. Gerri Trutanich says:

    Hello,

    I have been searching all over the net trying to find out if Sedona Mayor Sandy Moriarty is a Democrat or Republican.

    Gerri Trutanich

  34. FYI says:

    So it appears that others outside Sedona also rate the City Council a “F”
    They recognize “They are more concerned about LGBT pressure than religious freedom.” Same as the dealing with the chamber. They are more concerned with the pressure to pay for regional marketing then the health welfare and safety of the incorporated area.

    A cut out from the article is “And so we award culture scores of F to Mayor Sandy Moriarty, Vice Mayor Mark DiNunzio, and council members Scott Jablow, Angela LeFevre, John Martinez, Jon Thompson and Jessica Williamson. All of them possess very fervent imaginations … and a healthy fear of the LGBT movement. In fact, they are more afraid of the LGBT cultural Marxists than you. They are more concerned about LGBT pressure than religious freedom.”

    https://azconservative.org/category/homosexal-agenda/

  35. Gerri Trutanich says:

    I was also wondering what political affiliations do all the members and candidates run with. Not to say that I strictly vote my party (Democrat). I chose the candidate that best fits my values and concerns.

  36. Tony says:

    Mayor running unopposed. Everyone’s a Progressive Democrat supporting Hillary Clinton as far as I can tell and see most at DORR events. Bad business backgrounds that go hand in hand with their politics, know how to spend and take advantage of giveaways but not how to create jobs and give people food and work except for service industry, call it patriarchal white people living high off cheap hired help. Still the same old democrats that fought tooth and nail to keep slavery and Jim Crow laws. Learn your history and why Hispanics and Latinos and African-Americans are running away and back to Republicans and now finally a breath of fresh air, Trump. Remember even President Obamas brother is voting for him as a Muslim and African-American saying the democrats have it wrong on immigration and policy. But I’ve met very few democrats with the ability to think and reason without seeing a D after a candidate’s name.

  37. steve Segner says:

    FYI, said “They are more concerned about LGBT pressure than religious freedom.”

    “religious freedom: is the last thing government should be worried about.

    LGBT is “real” your religion is just your own belief, remember the separation of church and state our founders understood the danger of the church and organized
    religions.

  38. FYI says:

    Dah FYI didn’t say it was only reporting what was reported by a group. read the post.
    The city council should be focused on health welfare and safety for the incorporated area. Not to any special interest group like yours Steve. You are a regional membership based group that is stealing and misusing public funding that is intended for the incorporated city limits. Public funding private regional business Chamber is NOT why they city is here.

  39. Gerri Trutanich says:

    Thank you Tony but as far as I can tell… you are not sure. You are speculating. This is what I LOVE about this country. We can have different points of view and still respect and maintain our dignity so long as we are in formed with facts and personal experiences. You sound like a pretty informed guy and obviously a pro Trump supporter for this upcoming Presidential election. Hmmm. My first thought after reading your post was that he was kind enough to answer my question based on his experience. You went on to comment negative generalizations about the Democrats (somewhat true), how Republican D. Trump is synonymous to “a breath of fresh air” and you suggested “I learn my history”. I respect your opinion.
    Please understand, I am very cautious and aware, when reading information on the net or watching the media, of the differences between fact and fiction before making a decision.
    Look, I can go on and on about D. Trump and H. Clinton but at the end of the day, I do my research and vote on facts (their past histories) and conscious (what I feel is best for me and the country). Tony, no party is perfect. Our history shows both parties have had conflicting issues from day one. That’s what makes our Great Country Great. Talking it out, listening, respecting one another, coming up with creative solutions and especially both sides bending for the Good of all.
    As a newbie here in West Sedona (+1 yr.), and an avid voter all my life, I’ve been researching not only nationally but at the city level as well. I was curious and wanted to know what the Sedona’s City Council member’s and the upcoming candidate’s affiliations were. I know some people keep it confidential for fear of people assuming and/or generalizing what each party is supposed to represent. I guess it really doesn’t matter. What matters is their values, histories, work ethic and what they bring to the table to make this city the best it can be. It’s not easy being in their shoes. I commend them for their efforts.
    Thank you Sedona Eye for keeping us informed. Great article.
    Again, Thank You Tony for your post based on your experience. It helps.

  40. Tony says:

    Respect your reply.

  41. Terrio says:

    It’s all those Christians, Jews and Buddhists and others philosophy and practitioners protecting our LBGT communities. If you want to protect our gay and transgender communities, the same innocents fascists, socialists, atheist terrorists, and communists murder and have been murdering for centuries. tuck your poor education back in because it’s showing. It’s those people you despise practicing their BELIEF systems who vote and voted the changes in ourcountry today. BELIEF systems that include Christian, Jew, Buddhist, Mormon, Catholic, Orthodox, Muslim, Shinto and all other religions which we LBGTs believe in and represent and know how to spot a bigot from their writing.

  42. Just Another Opinion says:

    To Gerri Trutanich, you are, indeed, a class act and clearly a tough one to follow, especially since customarily on this web site vicious verbal attacks have become a common retaliation, and in most cases by unidentified individuals.

    In many instances it’s understandable why people prefer to remain anonymous because, unfortunately, repercussions could be costly. However, when someone’s sole intent is to assail another for whatever reason, it’s just a genuine display of a coward without a face or self respect.

    So for whatever it’s worth, here’s a stand up salute for bringing the caliber of Sedona Eye to the level it deserves in spite of those that constantly attempt to take it down. Good for you.

    Sincerely,

    Eddie Maddock

  43. Last Day to Register to Vote in Primary says:

    Monday, August 1, 2016, is the last day to register to vote or to change your party affiliation for the August 30, 2016 Primary Election. If you are a registered Independent, Other or Party Not Designated and are on the Permanent Early Voter List, you must tell the Yavapai County Elections office which party ballot you want mailed to you. Contact them as soon as possible at 928-771-3248 or go to yavapai.us/electionsvr/ (click on early ballot request).

  44. CC4A says:

    You’re Invited! It’s a free with popcorn Movie Night!

    “CLINTON CASH, THE UNTOLD STORY OF HOW FOREIGN GOVERNMENTS AND BUSINESSES MADE BILL AND HILLARY RICH”

    This is a change from our previous show plans.

    WHEN: Thursday, Augusty 4th, 6:30PM to 8:30PM
    (doors open at 6 PM)​
    WHERE:
    Canyon Trails Cowboy Church
    3132 White Bear Road
    Sedona, 86336

    About the Show: ​​This film is so important, we have decided to show it instead of what we previously planned:

    Join us for a movie night, with popcorn, to view this shocking documentary based on Peter Schweizer’s book. Learn how both Clintons became wealthy through influence peddling and “pay to play” schemes while she was Secretary of State and he was Chairman of the Clinton Global Initiative.

    Admission is free and all voters are welcome. Enjoy Popcorn with us! Be sure to tell and invite friends and family to join you.

  45. Wait a church is doing what? says:

    CC4A, and a few of you others who are always about the Constitution ,freedom, liberty…
    Here is a Church( a non profit) playing in the political field….
    I would love to see this church and any other not for profit lose there tax free cash cow!
    You have no solid ground to stand on.

  46. WSR says:

    Peter Schweizer Is a TEA PARTY member

    Take anything he’s nvoled in with a grain of salt…….

  47. @wait A church is doing what? says:

    What do the Democratic Party and a gang of criminals have in common? In the fall of 2014, outspoken author and filmmaker Dinesh Desousa found himself called into federal court for improperly donating money to a friend who ran for the Senate. He pleaded guilty, apologized for his offense, and was sentenced to eight months in the state confinement center near his home in San Diego. In the facility he lived among hardened criminals-drug dealers, the gangbangers, rapists and murderers. Now he is fundamentally transformed in his adopted country. It is precisely the WSRs who put Dinesh Desousa in prison and it is precisely the citizens that read this and do not comment who put Dinesh Desousa and – oh yes let’s all take responsibility for the videographer who Hillary Clinton and ilk blamed for her incompetence and the Democrats had arrested?

    Let’s hear it from the Rabbi, the priest, the minister, the tribal council elder, the Protestants, the Mormons, the Catholics, every laymen and laywomen, every educated American…WHY IS IT NOT A CRIME IN AMERICA TO HOLD A MEETING IN A CHURCH OR SCHOOL? WHY DOES IT HAVE NOTHING TO DO WITH CHURCH, STATE AND RELIGION?

  48. Wait a church is doing what? says:

    Yes you are so correct……I cant wait till one of our local churches start showing all the benefits of Sharia law!!!

    Be careful what you wish for….It just might come true….

    As for me…..I dont want anyone’s religion telling how to vote or think!!!!!

    So with your thinking, we might as well just remove the First Amendment then! You are part of the problem, not the solution.

  49. The Beat Goes On says:

    Once again the town crier, Steve Segner, received accolades at Tuesday’s council meeting (8/9) for having produced a brochure on behalf of the Lodging Council that they intend to sell for $8.00, proceeds allegedly to be given to the USFS for trail maintenance or some such thing

    The question is, what was the source of the money used to produce this costly booklet? The chamber of commerce, of course, was mentioned during the spiel given by one council member Jessica Williamson, a West Sedona resident, and, honestly, she just couldn’t say enough about how great was this latest contribution from Steve Segner, one and the same that paid half the cost for the recent mailer supporting her and other incumbents John Martinez, and Tom Lamkin to be elected for another stint on the city council.

    And guess what, all are strong advocates of the ongoing contract with the Chamber to promote Sedona and other various expenses which have never been audited by outside professionals. How would we survive without the likes of these givers, appropriately spelling would be TAKERS.

    Believe it or not, we would do very nicely without any of them as was proven since Sedona was discovered long before the C of C, in spite of their ongoing spouting that without them no one would even know Sedona existed. And the majority sitting on that council actually buy into that crock of crap? Wonder how many of them are here because of the chamber of commerce? Yet another addition to Sedona’s list of Truth vs Fantasy.

  50. West Sedona Dave says:

    And guess what, all are strong advocates of the ongoing contract with the Chamber to promote Sedona and other various expenses which have never been audited by outside professionals. How would we survive without the likes of these givers, appropriately spelling would be TAKERS.
    ————————————————————————————————————

    Here we go again…….I don’t believe they haven’t been audited, and by law if they couldn’t show there books, yes there is a problem….

    All these people with there problems just astound me…..Go there ask to see it, they dont show you, contact our states attorney……

    WHY ARE YOU PEOPLE WAITING????? Get off your buts and do something…..constant complaints and no one does a thing?

    I’m sick and tired of all the accusations and and complaints, and you just sit there and let it happen?…..Now that’s kinda strange in my book?

Leave a Reply

Copyright © 2008-2017 · Sedona Eye · All Rights Reserved · Posts · Comments · Facebook · Twitter ·