Yes, I too saw two articles re: Phoenix subsidizing shopping mall in the AZ Republic and the WSJ (the case is Turken v. Gordon) and was immediately struck by the implications this case may have on Sedona’s habit of subsidizing the Chamber ($622K and the Sedona Art Center $400K or so). In fact, if the appeal goes against Mayor Gordon, It would seem that Sedona businesses who do not belong to the Chamber would have grounds for a case against the City of Sedona.