Home » From The Readers, Letters to the Editor » Contraception Is Now Free Under Title 10

Contraception Is Now Free Under Title 10

Sedona AZ (February 14, 2012) – The following is a letter to the SedonaEye.com editor:

Hello Friends,

If the government announced it was giving everyone “free wine” because it reduces heart problems, promotes health, and lowers health care premiums, would you give Baptist Churches an exception?   Baptist Churches are against using wine and tell their members not to use it. Would you force Baptist Churches to participate in distributing the “free-wine” even though it is against their beliefs?

This Health Care Mandate forces the Catholic Church to participate in the distribution of contraceptives;  it does not matter that the insurance company will be doing the actual distribution of the contraceptives; the only reason the insurance company will distribute the so called “free” contraception is because the Catholic Church is buying its premiums. Which means the Catholic Church is providing contraceptives. This is no compromise; nothing is free.

As for the news, with its reports that “the majority of Catholics are in favor of contraceptives,” these ‘Catholics’ are not the ones required to purchase this health insurance; the Catholic Church is required to purchase it. If people were asked, “should the Catholic Church distribute free ice-cream to everybody,” most would be in favor.  

It does not matter if the majority of people believe in birth-control. Everybody used to believe that the world was flat; the world does not become flat just because everybody believes it to be true. This is a fallacy called argumentum ad populum, also known as the bandwagon fallacy. {Simply appealing to the fact that certain people believe something is true gives that belief no evidence of support at all. Lots of people believe lots of things—but the correlation between something’s being believed to be true by a lot of people and it actually being true is disappointingly weak. }

Didn’t Obama tell us that we could keep our current health care plan if we liked it, and that we would not have to switch? Well apparently not so for the Catholic Church. So, how is the government able to go against the Constitution, which clearly grants the Catholic Church freedom of religion? The 1st Amendment states:  Congress shall make no law … prohibiting the free exercise of religion.

So how can the government tell the Catholic Church to engage in practices against its beliefs? This is illegal, but the White House says that the Health Care Mandate gives the president this authority to override the 1st Amendment

So, what exactly is in this Health Care Mandate? If the government gets authority to take constitutional rights away from the Catholic Church by this Health Care Mandate, then what is in store for us? What rights will we have to give away? What kind of health care will the government allow us to have?  What exactly is in this 2,000 page mandate which legislators did not want to read before they passed it?  

If I were a catholic business woman I would resent the government’s telling me that I had to provide contraception for employees; this would be against my freedom to live out my religion. 

Contraception is already free under Title 10.  Click here: Title X Family Planning.

Janice Agnello
Maryland

For the best in Sedona news and views, read SedonaEye.com daily. Reach 4500+ subscribers with your ads and articles!

10 Comments

  1. Tracey McConnell says:

    The 2012 big & little Kids Book NOW AVAILABLE countywide – A Free Resource Guide to help Children and their Families!

    The 21st edition of The big & little Kids Book, a FREE resource guide of organizations serving Yavapai County children and their families, is now available for distribution.

    This guide contains detailed information on resources such as child care, clothing, counseling/support groups, disabilities/special needs, education, finances, food, health, hotlines, recreation/enrichment, service clubs, shelter/housing and transportation.

    Pick up the guides at the following locations: Public Libraries, Chambers of Commerce, the Department of Economic Security (Prescott and Cottonwood), Yavapai Regional Medical Center (Prescott and Prescott Valley), Verde Valley Regional Medical Center, the Step One Community Center (Prescott Valley), the Coalition for Compassion & Justice (Prescott United Methodist Church), at schools, and at nonprofit and public organizations serving children, youth and their families.

    Bulk copies are available from the Yavapai County Community Foundation (Prescott) and First Things First (Prescott) and Stepping Stones Agencies (Prescott Valley).

    In order to meet the rising need and increased public demand for countywide resource information supporting children, youth and their families, this year’s guide includes organizations in east as well as west Yavapai County, and 20,000 books will be distributed to hundreds of locations.

    This marks the highest number of books ever distributed, and the expanded outreach is made possible thanks to support from First Things First of Yavapai County, the Prescott Kiwanis Club, Yavapai Regional Medical Center, and the Yavapai County Community Foundation Children’s Fund.

    Production support was provided by: ACF/YCCF staff Tracey McConnell, Carol Chamberlain and Megan Brownell; First Things First Staff Cindy Pemberton and Lori Deutsch; Debbie Stewart with Stewart Communications; Deborah Darby with the United Way of Yavapai County; Barbara Polk. The project coordinator was Tracey McConnell, YCCF Grants and Operations Coordinator.

  2. MARLENE RAYNER says:

    Most ridiculous thing I’ve ever read. I was raised a catholic (but no longer believe), my mother a devout catholic emigrant from eastern Europe took me aside before I was married in 1964 and said ” The pope doesn’t support your family”. Those were powerful words from a smart woman. 98% of catholic women used birth control.

    Small operations within churches are excluded from the mandate. However, any entity which accepts federal dollars has to follow the law – thus hospitals, universities etc etc. No one is forcing anything. Birth control actually reduces insurance premiums. Catholics can follow their religion by not partaking of the free opportunity. Gosh wouldn’t it be better to not have insurance through employers, then it would not matter.

  3. Flagstaff Esquire says:

    the point is constitutional not pro or con birth control

  4. Mike Schroeder says:

    OK, so let me get this straight. This is in the Constitution…no. If a women has had all the children she wants, has had her tubes tied, she should pay for this? No. If a woman has been through menopause, she should still have to pay for this?.. No. When are you all going to get it through your thick skulls that one size does not fit all? No competition across state lines, no support for HSA, and no tort reform…and you call Obamacare the future? The Health Care Bill is a travesty of common sense and good practice. People who support it could care less about anyone but their own little personal situations. I am part of a company that has 24,000 total employees, of which are thrilled with our HSA program and competitive umbrella programs to pick and chose from to prevent losses on the big items. It is called PERSONAL FREEDOM! And the narrow minded control freaks that support this administration are taking what 80% + of the people in the US enjoy and are trying to screw it up.

  5. Glenn Shannon says:

    Birth control is a personal choice not a medical condition so health insurance should not pay for it. To me as a man it is discriminatory as it only pays for women nothing for men. Our insurance costs are at the point where many can’t afford them now, yet we just keep adding to the cost with no ending in sight. People start thinking for yourself as none of these people care about you just passing programs no matter what the cost to get votes.

  6. Janice says:

    They keep telling us how “good” the pill is for women’s health, this is all about “women,” “women’s health,” but the Pill does NOTHING to protect against AIDS or any STD.

    It is misleading when they say, “The Pill is good for women’s health,” because using the Pill can lead to a terminal illness.

    This current promotion of the Pill indicates how contraception use, in general, INCREASES sexually transmitted diseases. STDs have INCREASED since we have abundant contraception.

    Also, why is the divorce rate so high? If we really want to help poor people we need to address this issue because divorce contributes to poverty, and the Pill contributes to the divorce rate.

  7. Fr. Lawrence Adamczyk says:

    The side bar of my website http://wherethereispeter.blogspot.com/ has a big list of the consequences of contraception. Check it out.

    Fr. Larry
    Adamczyk, Rev. Lawrence

  8. Karen F. says:

    The righteousness of the Catholic Church is extremely offensive. Rather than spend it’s time outwardly attacking others about birth control, gay rights, divorce, abortion and other social issues in our society, perhaps the church needs to start seriously looking at it’s own social issues. It’s time for the church to keep it’s own child molesters away from our children, it’s own congregation from getting divorced, having abortions, using birth control and enforcing in it’s own congregation all the other prescribed doctrines proclaimed as unquestionably true by the church.

    Spare us please.

    -Karen (no last name/no address please)

  9. National Voter says:

    Churches who are 501 (c) 3 who do not agree with Federal policy need to relinquish their nonprofit status. They represent a minority of citizens. Why should a portion of voters who do not pay taxes, be allowed to steer public policy?

  10. Teresa J. says:

    Karen, at first I deleted your response here, but I am compelled to respond as a devout Catholic.

    I am sorry that you feel attacked. I am sorry that you feel that the Church hasn’t taken a look at its own problems…..but, that is not correct.

    We have our serious problems because we are human and sinful, but that doesn’t mean that we just give up or lay down when a fundamental belief is being attacked or worse yet being dismantled.

    If one of your children commits a serious crime and is imprisoned, do you just give up on your other kids? No, if anything you nurture and love them even more. And, that one in prison….you visit them.

    Artificial birth control is wrong in the eyes of the Church [God] because we believe that only God can start, prevent, and end life. This is the reason why we also don’t believe in abortion, euthanasia, the death penalty, etc.

    Please pray for us, and we for you.

    Teresa

Leave a Reply

Copyright © 2008-2017 · Sedona Eye · All Rights Reserved · Posts · Comments · Facebook · Twitter ·